The Molar Mass Trap: An Intermolecular Forces Lab

A one-day lab for Chemistry and Honors Chemistry (Unit 4: Covalent Bonding). Water is the lightest molecule in the lab at 18 g/mol, and mineral oil molecules are more than 15 times heavier. If molar mass were all that mattered, water would lose every contest. Students test four liquids and find out where water wins, where it loses, and which intermolecular forces (IMFs) explain each result. None of the liquids is flammable and no heat source is used. Plan on three 8-minute tests and about 10 minutes for cleanup and debrief, which fits a 45-minute period.

Lab Synopsis

Students work in groups of 3 or 4 and complete a short pre-lab first, in which they draw Lewis structures, list the IMFs for each liquid, and predict the results. They then compare water (tinted blue), glycerin, 1-octanol, and mineral oil (tinted red) in three tests, which they can do in any order:

  • Test 1, Cohesion: Three drops of each liquid go on wax paper. Water and glycerin pull into tall beads, while 1-octanol and mineral oil spread flat.
  • Test 2, Viscosity: Students time a steel shot falling through a sealed tube of each liquid. Glycerin is slowest by a wide margin, and mineral oil is next, even though it has no hydrogen bonding.
  • Test 3, Miscibility: Students mix five pairs of liquids and record one layer or two. The dyes show where each liquid ended up.

The debrief asks students to explain why a tiny hydrogen-bonding molecule beats a heavy nonpolar one in some contests and loses in others, and to finish the rule for when two liquids mix. A short lab quiz for the next class is in the teacher guide. For the background, see the Types of IMF and Properties Due to IMF lessons.

Skills Students Practice

  • Drawing Lewis structures and using them to identify the IMFs present
  • Ranking London dispersion, dipole-dipole, and hydrogen bonding by strength
  • Relating London dispersion strength to molecular size
  • Making a prediction and defending it with IMFs, then comparing it to data
  • Measuring a puddle diameter and timing a falling shot
  • Explaining why a larger molar mass does not always mean stronger attractions
  • Using “like dissolves like” to explain miscibility

Materials

Equipment (per group)

  • Chemical splash goggles and gloves
  • Four dropper bottles labeled W, G, O, and M
  • Wax paper square (about 15 cm by 15 cm) and a ruler
  • Marker, stopwatch (a phone is fine), and a magnet
  • 5 small test tubes with stoppers and a rack
  • A way to measure 1 mL and 0.5 mL, such as a graduated transfer pipette
  • Waste beaker and paper towels
  • Shared viscosity station: 4 sealed tubes, one per liquid, each with one steel shot

Chemicals

  • Water, H2O, tinted blue with FD&C Blue 1
  • Glycerin, C3H5(OH)3
  • 1-Octanol, C8H17OH
  • Mineral oil (a mixture of long alkanes), tinted red with Sudan III
  • Steel shot (sealed in the viscosity tubes)

The teacher preparation guide has the amount of each liquid for a class, how to build the viscosity stations, and a plan for how much 1-octanol to order. The answer key has the expected results for every table and question.

Station Setup

Line drawing of the lab setup. At each table: four dropper bottles labeled W, G, O, and M for water (blue), glycerin, 1-octanol, and mineral oil (red); a wax paper square divided into four boxes with a ruler; and five test tubes in a rack. A shared viscosity station has four sealed tubes, each with a steel shot.
Each group has four dropper bottles, wax paper and a ruler, and five test tubes. Groups share the sealed viscosity tubes.

Set up three or four viscosity stations around the room. Because the three tests can be done in any order, groups rotate through the stations without a queue.

Procedure

Test 1: Cohesion (Bead or Spread?)

Three panels for Test 1. Panel 1: a wax paper square with four boxes labeled W, G, O, and M, each with 3 drops. Panel 2: a side view at eye level showing a tall bead and a flat puddle. Panel 3: a top view of a puddle with its diameter d measured with a ruler in millimeters.
Three drops per box, a side view at eye level, then the diameter in millimeters.
  1. Divide the wax paper into four boxes labeled W, G, O, and M.
  2. Place 3 drops of each liquid in its box, all in one spot so they form a single puddle.
  3. Wait 30 seconds. Crouch to eye level with the bench and sketch the side view of each puddle.
  4. Measure the diameter of each puddle in mm. A smaller diameter means the liquid pulled itself into a taller bead.

Test 2: Viscosity (Steel Shot Race)

Three panels for Test 2. Panel 1: a sealed tube with a steel shot at the stopper end and a stopwatch marked START as the shot leaves the stopper. Panel 2: the shot at the bottom of the tube and a stopwatch marked STOP. Panel 3: a magnet beside the tube dragging the shot back up.
Start the stopwatch when the shot leaves the stopper, and stop it when the shot hits the bottom.
  1. Tilt a viscosity tube so the steel shot rests at the stopper end. Turn the tube upright and start the stopwatch the moment the shot leaves the stopper.
  2. Stop the stopwatch when the shot touches the bottom, and record the time.
  3. Do a second trial and average the two times. If the shot falls too fast to time, record “less than 0.5 s”.
  4. Use the magnet on the outside of the tube to drag the shot back to the stopper end for the next group. Never open a tube.

Test 3: Mix or Layer?

Three panels for Test 3. Panel 1: five test tubes numbered 1 to 5 in a rack as the liquids are added. Panel 2: a stoppered tube with arrows showing it inverted 5 times. Panel 3: two tubes side by side, one with a single layer and one with two layers.
Add the liquids, invert each tube 5 times, then look for one layer or two.
  1. Label five test tubes 1 to 5.
  2. Add 1 mL of each liquid to its tube, except use only 0.5 mL of 1-octanol. Stopper, invert gently 5 times, and let the tube stand for 1 minute.
  3. Record “one layer” or “two layers”. The blue and red dyes show where each liquid ended up.
  4. Pour all five mixtures into the labeled waste beaker.
TubePair
1Water + glycerin
2Water + mineral oil
3Water + 1-octanol
4Mineral oil + 1-octanol
5Glycerin + mineral oil

Safety

  • Students wear chemical splash goggles the whole period. No flames or heat sources are used.
  • Gloves for 1-octanol (skin and eye irritant) and the red mineral oil (the dye stains skin and clothing).
  • Wipe up glycerin and oil spills right away. Both make the floor and bench slippery.
  • Rinse skin contact with water. For eye contact, use the eyewash for 15 minutes. Report every spill.
  • Do not open the viscosity tubes. Nothing goes down the sink. Mixtures go in a labeled waste container, and wax paper goes in the trash.
ChemicalMain hazardsHandle it safely
Water, tinted blueLow hazard. The dye can stain.Wipe up spills.
GlycerinIrritant. Makes surfaces slippery.Wipe up spills right away. Keep away from eyes.
1-OctanolIrritates skin and eyes. Combustible.Wear gloves. Use only 0.5 mL per tube. Store away from heat.
Mineral oil, tinted redLow hazard. Sudan III stains skin and clothing. Makes surfaces slippery.Wear gloves. Wipe up spills right away.
Steel shot (sealed)Low hazard while sealed.Never open a viscosity tube. Move the shot with the magnet.

Review the current safety data sheet for each chemical before the lab.

Tips for Teachers

  • Do a full dry run. Mix all five pairs and time one set of viscosity tubes before students arrive. Tube size and fill height set the actual fall times, so you will want your own reference values.
  • Plan your 1-octanol. It is the limiting chemical. The guide works out about 90 mL for 8 groups over 5 periods, including the viscosity tubes.
  • Keep glycerin capped. It absorbs water from the air, and its viscosity drops.
  • Use the viscosity ranking as the main discussion. Glycerin is slowest, then mineral oil, then 1-octanol, then water. Water hydrogen bonds but is tiny. Mineral oil has no hydrogen bonds, but its very large molecules have strong London dispersion forces.
  • Listen for the molar mass trap. Students often say a bigger molar mass means stronger IMFs. Ask them to revisit their pre-lab rankings after the tests.
  • Let students drag the shot back with the magnet. Tubes stay sealed, and you can reuse them for every class and all year.
  • Dispense the 1-octanol yourself if you prefer to keep the only combustible liquid in your hands.
  • Assess it next class. The teacher guide ends with a 5-question lab quiz and its key, including two unknown liquids to identify from data.

Downloads

Everything on ZornScience is free to use in your classroom. If this saved you some prep time, you can buy me a coffee. Always appreciated, never expected.


NGSS Alignment

This lab builds toward this Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) performance expectation:

  • HS-PS1-3: Plan and conduct an investigation to gather evidence to compare the structure of substances at the bulk scale to infer the strength of electrical forces between particles.

Disciplinary core ideas: PS1.A Structure and Properties of Matter; PS2.B Types of Interactions

Science and engineering practices: Planning and Carrying Out Investigations; Analyzing and Interpreting Data; Constructing Explanations

Crosscutting concepts: Patterns