In this lesson
Take it with you
- Lesson slides (PDF)
- Practice worksheet (PDF)
- Answer key (PDF)
- AP Chemistry Unit 4 Practice (activity)
Essential Question
How can we tell if a new substance formed?
Ice melts, a nail rusts, a candle burns. Some changes make brand-new substances and some don’t. By the end of this lesson, you should be able to look at a change and use evidence to decide which kind it is.
Video not loading? Watch it on YouTube.
Physical Change
- Properties change, but composition does not.
- The same substance is there before and after.
- Phase changes, mixing, and separating mixtures are physical changes.

When ice melts, the water molecules move farther apart, but every particle is still H2O. Nothing new was made. Filtering sand out of water is also physical: the sand and water are just separated.
Chemical Change
- New substances form.
- Atoms rearrange into new combinations.
- A new substance has new properties.

Hydrogen and oxygen molecules react to make water: 2H2 + O2 → 2H2O. Count the atoms: 4 H and 2 O before, and 4 H and 2 O after. Atoms are never created or destroyed; they just trade partners. Hydrogen and oxygen are gases, but water is a liquid at room temperature, because it is a new substance.
Evidence of a Chemical Change

- Heat or light is produced, like when wood burns.
- A gas forms, seen as bubbles or fizzing.
- A precipitate forms, a solid that appears when two solutions are mixed.
- The color changes.
Any of these clues is possible evidence of a chemical change. As the next section shows, some physical changes can fool you.
Evidence Is Not Proof
- Bubbles can come from boiling, not reacting.
- Always ask: did a new substance form?

Both beakers have bubbles. In boiling water, the bubbles are water vapor, H2O(g), so no new substance formed: a physical change. When magnesium sits in hydrochloric acid, the bubbles are hydrogen gas, H2(g), which wasn’t there before: a chemical change. On the AP exam, back up your answer by naming the new substance or describing a new property.
Forming a Precipitate
- A precipitate is a solid that forms when two solutions mix.
- The mixture turns cloudy, then the solid settles.

Two clear solutions are poured together and a solid appears. That solid is a new substance that doesn’t dissolve in water, so it is strong evidence of a chemical change. Topic 4.2 shows how to write equations for these reactions.
Predicting What You Will See
If you know the products of a reaction, you can predict what you’ll observe before you mix anything:
| Product | Prediction |
|---|---|
| A gas (CO2, H2, O2) | Bubbles or fizzing |
| A solid from two solutions | A cloudy precipitate |
| Energy released | The container gets warmer, or you see light |
Saying “if this reaction happens, I expect to see this” is exactly the kind of hypothesis the AP exam asks you to write.
Worked Examples
Try each problem on your own first, then open the solution to check your work.
Example 1: Physical or Chemical?
Classify each change as physical or chemical: (a) ice melting, (b) iron rusting, (c) sugar dissolving in water, (d) wood burning.
Show the solution
- (a) Ice melting: the solid and the liquid are both water. Only the phase changed. Physical
- (b) Iron rusting: shiny gray iron becomes flaky reddish-brown rust, a new substance (iron oxide, Fe2O3). Chemical
- (c) Sugar dissolving: the sugar molecules spread out among the water molecules but are still sugar. Evaporate the water and you get the sugar back. Physical
- (d) Wood burning: heat and light are released, and the wood becomes ash, carbon dioxide, and water vapor. Chemical
Example 2: Zinc in Copper(II) Sulfate
A strip of zinc is placed in blue copper(II) sulfate solution. The blue color fades and a reddish-brown solid forms on the zinc. Is this a physical or chemical change? Give two pieces of evidence.
Show the solution
- Find the observations: “blue color fades” and “reddish-brown solid.”
- Evidence 1: a color change. The solution started blue and lost its color.
- Evidence 2: a new solid forms. Its reddish-brown color matches neither the zinc nor the blue solution. (It is copper metal.)
- Answer: Chemical change, because a new substance formed.
Example 3: Predict an Observation
Baking soda is added to vinegar. One product is carbon dioxide gas. Predict one observation, and explain why it is evidence of a chemical change.
Show the solution
- Key information: one product is a gas.
- Prediction: bubbles or fizzing when the two are mixed.
- Explain: CO2 wasn’t present in the baking soda or the vinegar before mixing, so it is a new substance.
- Answer: Bubbles of CO2 show that a new substance formed, so it is a chemical change.
Practice
- 4.1 Introduction for Reactions Practice Worksheet (PDF)
- 4.1 Introduction for Reactions Practice Answer Key (PDF)
Practice with instant feedback
Answer original AP-style questions for Unit 4 and see an explanation right after each one. Choose Topic 4.1 or mix topics. No login needed.
Lesson Slides
Big Ideas
- Physical change: same substance
- Chemical change: new substances
- Evidence: heat, light, gas, solid, color
- Confirm that a new substance formed
Back to the essential question: we look for evidence, then check whether the products really are different substances. Next up, Topic 4.2 shows how to write net ionic equations that show exactly which particles react.
AP Alignment
This lesson covers Topic 4.1, Introduction for Reactions, in Unit 4 (Chemical Reactions) of the College Board AP Chemistry Course and Exam Description (CED). Learning objective:
- 4.1.A: Identify evidence of chemical and physical changes in matter.
Essential knowledge: 4.1.A.1, 4.1.A.2
Suggested skill: 2.B Question and Method. Formulate a hypothesis or predict the results of an experiment.