AP Chemistry · Unit 4: Chemical Reactions

4.4 Physical and Chemical Changes

Essential Question

What really changes in a chemical change?

In Topic 4.1 we used observations like bubbles and color changes. This lesson zooms in to the particle level to look at what happens to bonds and attractions. By the end, you should be able to support a claim about a change using evidence and particle-level reasoning.

Video not loading? Watch it on YouTube.

Bonds vs. Intermolecular Forces

  • Bond: holds atoms together inside a particle.
  • IMF (intermolecular force): an attraction between separate particles.
  • Bonds are much stronger than IMFs.
Two water molecules drawn as balls and sticks. Solid sticks inside each molecule are labeled bond; a dashed blue line between them is labeled IMF.

In each water molecule, the solid lines are covalent O-H bonds. The dashed line is a hydrogen bond between two water molecules, which is an IMF. The difference in strength is the key to telling physical and chemical changes apart.

Physical Change: Only IMFs Change

  • Phase changes overcome IMFs.
  • The molecules stay whole.
H2O(l) box with water molecules close together, arrow, H2O(g) box with the same intact water molecules far apart.

In liquid water, the molecules are close together, held by IMFs. In the gas, they are far apart. Every molecule is still H2O: the O-H bonds inside each molecule did not break. Processes that only change IMFs, like phase changes, are physical changes.

Chemical Change: Bonds Break and Form

  • Bonds inside particles break.
  • New bonds form new substances.
2H2O to 2H2 + O2. Before box: two water molecules. After box: two H2 molecules and one O2 molecule.

When electricity splits water, 2H2O → 2H2 + O2, the O-H bonds break. Then new bonds form: H-H bonds in hydrogen gas and an O=O bond in oxygen gas. New substances with new properties are made, so this is a chemical change.

Comparing the Two Changes

Boiling waterSplitting water
What is overcome or brokenIMFsCovalent bonds
ProductsH2O(g), still waterH2 and O2, new substances
Energy neededSomeMuch more

Splitting water takes much more energy than boiling it, because breaking bonds takes more energy than overcoming IMFs.

Dissolving: A Gray Area

  • Ionic bonds in the crystal break.
  • Ion-dipole attractions form.
  • It can be argued either way.
A small NaCl crystal of alternating ions, arrow, then a Na+ ion surrounded by water molecules with oxygen facing in and a Cl- ion surrounded by water molecules with hydrogen facing in.

When sodium chloride dissolves, the ionic bonds holding the crystal together break, which sounds chemical. At the same time, new attractions form between the ions and water. The negative oxygen end of each water molecule faces Na+, and the positive hydrogen end faces Cl−. These ion-dipole attractions are IMFs. The AP framework says dissolving can be argued either way, as long as you support your claim with reasoning about bonds and attractions.

Supporting Your Claim

On the AP exam, you’ll often support a claim with evidence from data. A strong answer has three parts:

  1. Claim: is the change physical or chemical?
  2. Evidence: data or observations, like a mass change, a new color, or a gas released.
  3. Reasoning: what happened at the particle level. Did bonds break and form, or were only IMFs overcome?

↑ Back to top


Worked Examples

Try each problem on your own first, then open the solution to check your work.

Example 1: Heating Iodine

Solid iodine is heated and turns directly into a purple gas. When it cools, dark gray crystals form again. Is this a physical or chemical change? Give a particle-level justification.

Show the solution
  1. Write what happens: I2(s) → I2(g). Iodine exists as I2 molecules in both phases. Going straight from solid to gas is called sublimation.
  2. Evidence: the original dark gray crystals re-form on cooling, so no new substance was made.
  3. Reasoning: heating overcomes the London dispersion forces between I2 molecules. The I-I covalent bond inside each molecule stays intact.
  4. Claim: Physical change, because only intermolecular forces changed.

Example 2: Using Data

A student heats 10.0 g of a white solid. A gas is released that turns limewater cloudy. Afterward, 5.6 g of a different white solid remains. Is this a physical or chemical change? Support your claim with evidence.

Show the solution
  1. Evidence 1: the mass of the solid decreased from 10.0 g to 5.6 g.
  2. Where did the mass go? Mass is conserved, so 10.0 g − 5.6 g = 4.4 g left as a gas.
  3. Evidence 2: the gas turns limewater cloudy, the test for CO2. A gas that wasn’t there before is a new substance, and the solid left behind is a different substance too.
  4. Reasoning: for a new gas and a different solid to form, bonds in the original solid had to break and new bonds had to form.
  5. Claim: Chemical change. (It is calcium carbonate breaking down: CaCO3(s) → CaO(s) + CO2(g). You didn’t need to know that; the evidence was enough.)

↑ Back to top


Practice

Each problem shows a particle diagram and some observations. Write a claim, evidence, and reasoning for each one, then check your work with the answer key.

Practice with instant feedback

Answer original AP-style questions for Unit 4 and see an explanation right after each one. Choose Topic 4.4 or mix topics. No login needed.

↑ Back to top


Lesson Slides

↑ Back to top


Big Ideas

  • Bonds: inside particles
  • IMFs: between particles
  • Physical: only IMFs change
  • Chemical: bonds break and form
  • Dissolving can be argued either way

Back to the essential question: in a chemical change, the bonds change. Atoms rearrange into new combinations, making new substances. Next up, Topic 4.5 uses balanced equations to calculate how much product a reaction makes.

↑ Back to top


AP Alignment

This lesson covers Topic 4.4, Physical and Chemical Changes, in Unit 4 (Chemical Reactions) of the College Board AP Chemistry Course and Exam Description (CED). Learning objective:

  • 4.4.A: Explain the relationship between macroscopic characteristics and bond interactions for: i. Chemical processes. ii. Physical processes.

Essential knowledge: 4.4.A.1, 4.4.A.2

Suggested skill: 6.B Argumentation. Support a claim with evidence from experimental data.

↑ Back to top