AP Chemistry · Unit 2: Compound Structure and Properties

2.6 Resonance and Formal Charge

Essential Question

How do we choose the best Lewis structure?

Up to now, you’ve drawn one Lewis structure for each molecule. But sometimes more than one structure follows all the rules. By the end of this lesson, you should know when to blend those structures together and when to use formal charge to pick the best one.

Video not loading? Watch it on YouTube.

Resonance Structures

  • Sometimes more than one valid Lewis structure can be drawn for the same molecule or ion.
  • These are called resonance structures. The atoms stay in the same places; only the electrons are arranged differently.
Two resonance structures of ozone joined by a double-headed arrow. Left: O=O–O with the double bond on the left. Right: O–O=O with the double bond on the right. Lone pairs complete each oxygen's octet.

Ozone, O3, has 18 valence electrons (3 × 6). The central oxygen needs a double bond to complete everyone’s octet, and it could go to either outer oxygen. Both structures follow every rule. Resonance structures are connected by one double-headed arrow (↔). This is not the equilibrium symbol, and it does not mean a reaction is happening.

Drawing Resonance Structures

  • Move only lone pairs and double bonds.
  • Atoms never move. Moving an atom gives a different molecule, not a resonance structure.
  • Every resonance structure has the same total number of electrons.
Three resonance structures of the nitrate ion, numbered 1 to 3, each in brackets with a minus charge and joined by double-headed arrows. Nitrogen is in the center bonded to three oxygens, and the N=O double bond moves from the top oxygen to the lower-left oxygen to the lower-right oxygen.

The nitrate ion, NO3−, has 5 + 3(6) + 1 = 24 valence electrons. Nitrogen needs one N=O double bond for an octet, and that double bond could go to any of the three oxygens, so nitrate has three resonance structures. To get from one to the next, a lone pair becomes a bond and a bond becomes a lone pair. Because nitrate is an ion, each structure goes in brackets with the charge outside.

The Resonance Hybrid

  • The real molecule is a blend of all its resonance structures, called the resonance hybrid.
  • It does not flip back and forth between the structures.
The resonance hybrid of ozone, O–O–O with each bond drawn as a solid line plus a dashed line. Below, three bond lengths: O–O single bond 148 pm, both bonds in O3 128 pm (highlighted), O=O double bond 121 pm.

In ozone, the extra pair of bonding electrons is spread out over both bonds, shown with a solid line plus a dashed line. Think of a mule, a cross between a horse and a donkey: a mule isn’t a horse one second and a donkey the next. It’s always a mule.

The evidence: a typical O–O single bond is about 148 pm and a typical O=O double bond is about 121 pm. Both bonds in ozone measure 128 pm. They are identical, and their length is in between a single and a double bond. One Lewis structure can’t explain that, but the hybrid can.

Bond Order in a Hybrid

Bond order is the number of bonds between two atoms: 1 for a single bond, 2 for a double bond, and 3 for a triple bond. For a resonance hybrid, take the average.

The ozone resonance hybrid with each O–O bond labeled 1.5. Below: O3: 3 bonds ÷ 2 locations = 1.5.
  • Average bond order = total bonds ÷ number of bond locations
  • Ozone: one double bond (2) + one single bond (1) = 3 bonds, shared over 2 locations, so 3 ÷ 2 = 1.5
  • Higher bond order → shorter, stronger bond. A bond order of 1.5 falls between a single and a double bond, and so does the bond length.

Formal Charge

FC = V − N − ½B

  • V = valence electrons of the neutral atom (from the group number)
  • N = nonbonding electrons on that atom (count every dot)
  • B = bonding electrons on that atom (2 for every line)

Since ½B is just the number of lines touching the atom, here’s the shortcut: FC = valence electrons − (dots + lines). Formal charge is a bookkeeping tool for comparing Lewis structures. It is not a real charge on the atom, and it is not the same as a partial charge from electronegativity.

Adding Up Formal Charges

  • Find the formal charge on every atom.
  • The sum of the formal charges equals the overall charge of the molecule or ion.
Ozone Lewis structure O=O–O with formal charges written below each atom: 0 on the left oxygen, +1 on the center oxygen, −1 on the right oxygen. Below: 0 + (+1) + (−1) = 0.

For this ozone structure: the left O is 6 − 4 − 2 = 0, the center O is 6 − 2 − 3 = +1, and the right O is 6 − 6 − 1 = −1. The sum is 0, which matches neutral O3. Checking the sum is a quick way to catch mistakes.

Choosing the Best Structure

When two or more structures are possible and they are not equivalent, use these rules in order:

  1. Octets: give atoms octets. C, N, O, and F never go over an octet.
  2. Formal charges as close to zero as possible: fewer and smaller formal charges make a more stable structure.
  3. The tiebreaker: any negative formal charge should be on the most electronegative atom, the one that pulls electrons the hardest.

Exam tip: when you justify which structure is best, name these rules as your evidence.

Equivalent vs. Nonequivalent

  • Equivalent structures have the same pattern with the bonds in different spots (examples: O3, NO3−). Every structure is equally good, so use resonance and blend them.
  • Nonequivalent structures have different formal charge patterns (examples: CO2, OCN−). They are not equally good, so use formal charge to pick the best one. The best structure is the best model for predicting the molecule’s shape and properties.

Limitations of the Lewis Model

  • Every model has limits.
  • An odd number of valence electrons means one electron is left unpaired.
  • At least one atom can’t have an octet.
Lewis structure of NO: N=O with one lone pair and one unpaired electron (red dot) on nitrogen and two lone pairs on oxygen. Caption: NO: 5 + 6 = 11 valence electrons. N has only 7 electrons.

Nitrogen monoxide, NO, has 5 + 6 = 11 valence electrons. Bonds and lone pairs both use electrons in pairs, so one electron is always left over. Around nitrogen there are 4 electrons in the double bond, 2 in the lone pair, and 1 unpaired electron, for a total of only 7. A molecule with an unpaired electron is called a free radical, and radicals tend to be very reactive.

↑ Back to top


Worked Examples

Try each problem on your own first, then open the solution to check your work.

Example 1: Drawing Resonance Structures

Draw all resonance structures for the nitrite ion, NO2−.

Show the solution
  1. Count valence electrons: N = 5, two O = 2 × 6 = 12, and the negative charge adds 1. Total = 5 + 12 + 1 = 18 electrons.
  2. Draw the skeleton: put N in the middle and connect O–N–O with single bonds. Two bonds use 4 electrons, leaving 18 − 4 = 14.
  3. Fill the outer atoms: give each O three lone pairs (12 electrons). The last 2 electrons go on N as a lone pair.
  4. Check the central atom: N has 2 bonds and 1 lone pair, only 6 electrons. It needs an octet.
  5. Make a double bond: turn one oxygen lone pair into an N=O double bond. It can be the left oxygen or the right oxygen, and both are equally good.
  6. Answer: nitrite has two equivalent resonance structures, each in brackets with the minus charge and joined by a double-headed arrow.
The two resonance structures of the nitrite ion, each in brackets with a minus charge, joined by a double-headed arrow. Left: O=N–O. Right: O–N=O. Nitrogen has one lone pair, the double-bonded oxygen has two lone pairs, and the single-bonded oxygen has three.

Check with formal charge: double-bonded O = 6 − 4 − 2 = 0, N = 5 − 2 − 3 = 0, single-bonded O = 6 − 6 − 1 = −1. The sum is −1, which matches the ion’s charge. Since the structures are equivalent, each N–O bond in the hybrid has a bond order of 1.5.

Example 2: Calculating Formal Charge

Calculate the formal charge on each atom in this Lewis structure of the thiocyanate ion, SCN−.

Lewis structure of the thiocyanate ion in brackets with a minus charge: S=C=N, with two lone pairs on sulfur, none on carbon, and two lone pairs on nitrogen.
Show the solution
  1. Formula: FC = valence electrons − (dots + lines)
  2. Sulfur: group 16, so V = 6. It has 4 dots and 2 lines. FC = 6 − 4 − 2 = 0
  3. Carbon: group 14, so V = 4. It has 0 dots and 4 lines (two double bonds). FC = 4 − 0 − 4 = 0
  4. Nitrogen: group 15, so V = 5. It has 4 dots and 2 lines. FC = 5 − 4 − 2 = −1
  5. Check the sum: 0 + 0 + (−1) = −1, which matches the ion’s −1 charge.
  6. Answer: S = 0, C = 0, N = −1

Example 3: Choosing the Best Structure

Two Lewis structures for N2O are shown. Which is the better model? Justify your answer using formal charge.

Two Lewis structures for N2O. Structure A: N=N=O with two lone pairs on the end nitrogen and two on oxygen. Structure B: N≡N–O with one lone pair on the end nitrogen and three on oxygen.
Show the solution
  1. Structure A: end N = 5 − 4 − 2 = −1, middle N = 5 − 0 − 4 = +1, O = 6 − 4 − 2 = 0
  2. Structure B: end N = 5 − 2 − 3 = 0, middle N = 5 − 0 − 4 = +1, O = 6 − 6 − 1 = −1
  3. Rules 1 and 2: both structures give every atom an octet, and both have one +1 and one −1. That’s a tie.
  4. Rule 3, the tiebreaker: oxygen is more electronegative than nitrogen, so the negative formal charge belongs on oxygen.
  5. Answer: Structure B is the better model.

Sample exam justification: Structure B is better. Both structures give every atom an octet and have the same formal charge magnitudes, but in structure B the −1 formal charge is on oxygen, the most electronegative atom.

Example 4: Average Bond Order

One resonance structure of the carbonate ion, CO32−, is shown. Find the average C–O bond order. How do the three C–O bond lengths compare?

One resonance structure of the carbonate ion in brackets with a 2− charge: carbon in the center double-bonded to the top oxygen and single-bonded to two lower oxygens, with lone pairs on each oxygen.
Show the solution
  1. Count the total bonds: one double bond (2) + two single bonds (1 + 1) = 4 bonds
  2. Count the bond locations: carbon is bonded to 3 oxygens, so there are 3 locations.
  3. Divide: 4 ÷ 3 = 1.33
  4. Answer: average C–O bond order = 1.33
  5. Bond lengths: carbonate has three equivalent resonance structures, so the real ion is an equal blend. All three C–O bonds are identical in length, shorter than a C–O single bond but longer than a C=O double bond.

Example 5: Odd Electrons

Nitrogen dioxide, NO2, has 17 valence electrons. Explain why no Lewis structure for NO2 can give every atom an octet.

Show the solution
  1. Evidence: N = 5 and each O = 6, so 5 + 6 + 6 = 17 valence electrons, an odd number.
  2. Reasoning: in a Lewis structure, bonds and lone pairs both use electrons in pairs. 17 electrons can’t be split evenly into pairs, so one electron is always left unpaired.
  3. Answer: the atom holding the unpaired electron, usually nitrogen, has only 7 electrons, so no Lewis structure can give every atom an octet.

Sample exam justification: NO2 has 17 valence electrons. Because electrons in a Lewis structure are placed in pairs, an odd total leaves one unpaired electron, so at least one atom has fewer than 8 electrons. This is a limitation of the Lewis model.

↑ Back to top


Practice

Practice Lewis structures and shapes

Count valence electrons, build each Lewis structure, then predict its shape, bond angle and polarity.

Practice with instant feedback

Answer original AP-style questions for Unit 2 and see an explanation right after each one. Choose Topic 2.6 or mix topics. No login needed.

↑ Back to top


Lesson Slides

↑ Back to top


Big Ideas

  • Resonance: more than one valid Lewis structure can be drawn.
  • The real molecule is the resonance hybrid.
  • FC = V − N − ½B (valence − dots − lines).
  • Best structure: formal charges near 0, with any negative formal charge on the most electronegative atom.

Back to the essential question: if the possible structures are equivalent, blend them into a resonance hybrid. If they’re not, use octets and formal charge to pick the best one. Next up, Topic 2.7 uses these Lewis structures to predict molecular shapes with VSEPR.

↑ Back to top


AP Alignment

This lesson covers Topic 2.6, Resonance and Formal Charge, in Unit 2 (Compound Structure and Properties) of the College Board AP Chemistry Course and Exam Description (CED). Learning objective:

  • 2.6.A: Represent a molecule with a Lewis diagram that accounts for resonance between equivalent structures or that uses formal charge to select between nonequivalent structures.

Essential knowledge: 2.6.A.1, 2.6.A.2, 2.6.A.3

Suggested skill: 6.C Argumentation. Support a claim with evidence from representations or models at the particulate level, such as the structure of atoms and/or molecules.

↑ Back to top