In this lesson
- Video lesson (coming soon)
- Lesson notes
- Worked examples
- Big ideas
- AP alignment
Take it with you
- Lesson slides (PDF)
- Practice worksheet (PDF)
- Answer key (PDF)
- pH & Buffer Lab (activity)
- AP Chemistry Unit 8 Practice (activity)
Essential Question
How does pH decide an acid’s form?
By the end of this lesson, you should be able to compare the pH of a solution to the pKa of a weak acid to predict whether HA or A− dominates, and use that idea to explain how acid-base indicators change color and how to choose one for a titration.
Video lesson coming soon. In the meantime, read through the lesson below.
Two Forms: HA and A−
- HA is the acid form: it still has its H+.
- A− is the base form: it has lost its H+.
- The pH of the solution decides which form wins.
HA + H2O ⇌ H3O+ + A−

Every weak acid can exist in two forms. HA is the protonated form: it still has its hydrogen ion attached, so it is called the acid form. When HA gives away that H+, what is left behind is A−, the deprotonated form. A− is the conjugate base, so it is called the base form. Because the reaction with water is an equilibrium, both forms are always present in the solution, and the real question is which form there is more of. At high pH, where there is very little H+ around, the acid tends to lose its proton. At low pH, where there is lots of H+ around, A− tends to pick one back up.
Compare pH to pKa
- pH < pKa: more HA
- pH > pKa: more A−

Every weak acid has a pKa, and the pKa acts like a dividing line on the pH scale. To figure out which form of the acid dominates, compare the pH of the solution to the pKa of the acid. If the pH is below the pKa, the solution has lots of H+, so the acid holds on to its proton and HA dominates. If the pH is above the pKa, there is very little H+, so the acid gives its proton away and A− dominates. The AP exam loves asking which species is present at a higher concentration at a given pH: just compare pH to pKa and say which one is bigger.
When pH = pKa
- When pH = pKa, [HA] = [A−].
- Half the acid is HA and half is A−.
- This is the 50/50 point.

Right at the dividing line, when the pH exactly equals the pKa, the two forms are present in equal amounts. The concentration of HA equals the concentration of A−, so half the acid is in the acid form and half is in the base form. For example, acetic acid has a pKa of 4.74. In a solution at pH 4.74, half of the acetic acid is CH3COOH and half is acetate, CH3COO−. Lower the pH and HA takes over; raise it and A− takes over. This should sound familiar from titrations: at the half-equivalence point of a weak acid titration, half the acid has been converted to A−, so pH = pKa. That is a favorite AP exam connection.
Distribution Diagram
- Shows the fraction of each form vs. pH
- The curves cross at pH = pKa
- Acetic acid: pKa = 4.74

A distribution diagram shows what fraction of an acid is in each form at every pH. For acetic acid, the red curve is HA and the blue curve is A−. At any pH, the two fractions add up to 1, because every acid particle is in one form or the other. The curves cross at a fraction of 0.5, right at pH 4.74, which is the pKa. To the left of the pKa, the HA curve is on top, so HA dominates; to the right, the A− curve is on top. Notice how fast it switches: within about one or two pH units of the pKa, the acid flips almost completely from one form to the other.
Indicators Are Weak Acids
- An indicator is a weak acid, written HIn.
- HIn and In− have different colors.
HIn + H2O ⇌ H3O+ + In−

An acid-base indicator is just a weak acid. It is written as HIn, where In stands for indicator, and like any weak acid it can lose its proton to become In−. The trick is that the two forms have different colors. For bromothymol blue, the acid form, HIn, is yellow, and the base form, In−, is blue. So the color of the solution tells you which form dominates. What controls which form dominates is the pH compared to the pKa: in acidic solution the indicator stays as yellow HIn, and in basic solution it becomes blue In−. That is the whole reason indicators respond to pH.
Indicator Color Range
- The color changes near pH = pKa.
- The color change range is about pKa ± 1.

Consider an indicator with a pKa of 5.0 whose HIn form is red and whose In− form is yellow. The color changes right around the pKa, because that is where the two forms switch places. Our eyes need one form to be about ten times more plentiful than the other before we see just that one color, and that happens about one pH unit away from the pKa. So a good rule of thumb is that the color changes over a range of about pKa ± 1. For this indicator that is from about pH 4 to pH 6, and in the middle we see a mix, which looks orange. Below pH 4 it is red, and above pH 6 it is yellow. Real indicators have ranges close to, but not exactly, pKa ± 1, so treat this as a good estimate.
Choosing an Indicator
- Choose an indicator with a pKa near the equivalence pH.
- Then the color flips right at the equivalence point.
Indicator pKa ≈ equivalence pH

In a titration, an indicator signals when the equivalence point has been reached. For that to work, the color has to change right at the equivalence point, not before and not after. Since the color changes near the pKa, choose an indicator whose pKa is close to the pH at the equivalence point. Methyl orange (pKa ≈ 3.5) fits a titration with an acidic equivalence point, like a weak base titrated with a strong acid. Bromothymol blue (pKa ≈ 7.1) fits a strong acid with a strong base, where the equivalence pH is 7. Phenolphthalein (pKa ≈ 9.4) fits a weak acid titrated with a strong base, where the equivalence pH is above 7. On the AP exam, find the equivalence pH, pick the indicator whose pKa is closest to it, and say exactly that in your justification.
Worked Examples
Try each problem on your own first, then open the solution to check your work.
Example 1: Which Form Dominates?
Hypochlorous acid, HOCl, has a pKa of 7.53. A solution of HOCl is adjusted to pH 7.00. Which species is present at the higher concentration, HOCl or OCl−? Justify your answer.
Show the solution
- Known: HA = HOCl (acid form, still has its proton) and A− = OCl−, hypochlorite (base form).
- Claim: HOCl is present at the higher concentration.
- Evidence: pH = 7.00 < pKa = 7.53.
- Reasoning: When the pH is below the pKa, the acid form dominates. Because the solution pH of 7.00 is less than the pKa of HOCl, 7.53, the protonated form, HOCl, is present at a higher concentration than OCl−.
- Answer: [HOCl] > [OCl−]
Common trap: a neutral pH of 7 does not mean the acid must be mostly ionized. The pKa of HOCl is above 7, so at pH 7 it is still mostly in the acid form. Always compare to the pKa, not to 7.
Example 2: Pick the Indicator
A weak base is titrated with HCl. The pH at the equivalence point is about 5.3. Which indicator is the best choice: methyl orange (pKa = 3.5), methyl red (pKa = 5.0), or bromothymol blue (pKa = 7.1)? Justify your answer.
Show the solution
- Known: The indicator changes color near its pKa, so the best indicator has a pKa ≈ equivalence pH = 5.3.
- Calculate: Methyl orange: |3.5 − 5.3| = 1.8. Methyl red: |5.0 − 5.3| = 0.3. Bromothymol blue: |7.1 − 5.3| = 1.8.
- Claim: Methyl red is the best choice.
- Reasoning: Methyl red’s pKa of 5.0 is closest to the equivalence point pH of about 5.3, so it will change color at or very near the equivalence point.
- Answer: Methyl red
Common trap: picking bromothymol blue because 7 sounds like the end of a titration. A weak base titrated with a strong acid has an equivalence point below 7, because the conjugate acid of the weak base makes the solution acidic. Bromothymol blue would change color too early, before the equivalence point.
Example 3: Predict the Color
Phenolphthalein has a pKa of 9.4. Its HIn form is colorless and its In− form is pink. A few drops are added to a solution with pH 6.0. What color is the solution? Justify your answer.
Show the solution
- Known: pKa = 9.4, pH = 6.0. HIn is colorless and In− is pink.
- Claim: The solution is colorless.
- Evidence: pH = 6.0 < pKa = 9.4. In fact, 6.0 is well below pKa − 1 = 8.4, outside the color change range of roughly pKa ± 1.
- Reasoning: When the pH is below the pKa, the protonated form, HIn, dominates. Because the solution pH of 6.0 is less than the indicator’s pKa of 9.4, HIn is present at a much higher concentration than In−, so the solution shows the color of HIn, which is colorless.
- Answer: colorless
Common trap: a pH above 7 is not enough to turn phenolphthalein pink. A solution at pH 8 is basic, but it would still be colorless, because the color only changes near the pKa of 9.4.
Example 4: Ratio Above pKa
HF has a pKa of 3.17. In a solution with pH 4.17, is the ratio [F−]/[HF] greater than 1, less than 1, or equal to 1? Justify your answer.
Show the solution
- Known: HF = HA (acid form) and F− = A− (base form). The ratio has the base form on top and the acid form on the bottom.
- Claim: The ratio is greater than 1.
- Evidence: pH = 4.17 > pKa = 3.17, so [F−] > [HF].
- Reasoning: When pH is above pKa, the base form dominates. Because the pH of 4.17 is greater than the pKa of HF, 3.17, F− is present at a higher concentration than HF. A bigger number on top divided by a smaller number on the bottom gives a ratio greater than 1.
- Answer: [F−]/[HF] > 1
Common trap: flipping the ratio, so always check which species is on top. Sneak peek: since the pH is exactly one unit above the pKa, the ratio is actually 10. You will see why in Topic 8.9.
Practice
Run the pH & Buffer Lab
The lab opens in Buffer Builder mode with acetic acid and acetate. Change the ratio of A− to HA, test Henderson-Hasselbalch, and see that pH equals pKa when the two forms are equal. No login needed.
Practice with instant feedback
Answer original AP-style questions for Unit 8 and see an explanation right after each one. Choose Topic 8.7 or mix topics. No login needed.
Lesson Slides
Big Ideas
- pH < pKa: HA dominates.
- pH > pKa: A− dominates.
- Indicator pKa ≈ equivalence pH.
- pH = pKa: [HA] = [A−], the 50/50 point.
Exam tip: On a which-species-dominates question, write the comparison explicitly, for example pH 7.00 < pKa 7.53, and then name the form that dominates. Compare to the pKa, never to pH 7.
Back to the essential question: pH decides an acid’s form by comparison to the acid’s pKa. Below the pKa, the acid keeps its proton and HA dominates; above the pKa, it gives the proton away and A− dominates. Next up, Topic 8.8 looks at buffers, solutions that hold large amounts of both HA and A− so they can resist changes in pH.
AP Alignment
This lesson covers Topic 8.7, pH and pKa, in Unit 8 (Acids and Bases) of the College Board AP Chemistry Course and Exam Description (CED). Learning objective:
- 8.7.A: Explain the relationship between the predominant form of a weak acid or base in solution at a given pH and the pKa of the conjugate acid or the pKb of the conjugate base.
Essential knowledge: 8.7.A.1, 8.7.A.2, 8.7.A.3
Suggested skill: 2.D Question and Method. Make observations or collect data from representations of laboratory setups or results, while attending to precision where appropriate.