Chemistry · Quantum

Ions and Exceptions

Essential Question

How do electrons change when atoms form ions?

In Noble Gas Notation, you learned to write electron configurations in full notation, in noble gas notation, and with orbital box diagrams. Now you will use those same skills on ions. By the end of this lesson, you should be able to write configurations for positive and negative ions, identify ions that are isoelectronic, remove electrons correctly from transition metals, and explain the two big exceptions, chromium and copper.

Video not loading? Watch it on YouTube.

What Is an Ion?

  • Ion: an atom that gained or lost e−
  • Cation: lost e−, so it is (+)
  • Anion: gained e−, so it is (−)
Bohr model of a sodium atom with 11 protons and electrons arranged 2, 8, 1. An arrow labeled loses 1 electron points to a Na+ ion with 11 protons and electrons arranged 2, 8, while the single outer electron flies away.

An ion is an atom with a charge because it has gained or lost electrons. The key idea is that the protons never change, since the number of protons decides which element you are. Only the electrons move. A sodium atom has 11 protons and 11 electrons, arranged 2, 8, 1, and that lonely outer electron is easy to lose. Once it leaves, sodium still has 11 protons but only 10 electrons, so 11 − 10 leaves a charge of 1+. Positive ions (cations) lost electrons, and negative ions (anions) gained electrons, so anions have more electrons than protons.

Atoms Want a Noble Gas Configuration

  • Main-group atoms gain or lose e−
  • Goal: full s and p, like a noble gas
The first four rows of the periodic table with common ion charges above each main-group column: group 1 is 1+, group 2 is 2+, group 13 is 3+, group 15 is 3−, group 16 is 2−, group 17 is 1−, and the noble gases are 0. The transition metals in the middle are labeled charges vary. Metals on the left lose electrons to form cations, and nonmetals on the right gain electrons to form anions.

The noble gases (helium, neon, argon, krypton) have full s and p sublevels, and they almost never react. That arrangement is very stable, so main-group atoms gain or lose electrons until they match the nearest noble gas. Metals on the left are close to the noble gas before them, so they lose electrons: group 1 loses 1, group 2 loses 2, and group 13 loses 3. Nonmetals on the right are close to the next noble gas, so they gain electrons: group 17 gains 1, group 16 gains 2, and group 15 gains 3. Group 14 would have to move 4 electrons either way, so those atoms usually share electrons instead, and the transition metals can form more than one charge.

Configurations of Anions

  • Anions: add e− to the open orbitals
Top row: F atom, 9 electrons, 1s2 2s2 2p5, with orbital boxes showing the last 2p box holding only one up arrow. A red arrow labeled gains 1 electron points down to the F− ion row: 10 electrons, 1s2 2s2 2p6, where a red down arrow fills the last 2p box. Bottom line: [He] 2s2 2p5 becomes [He] 2s2 2p6, which equals [Ne].

Anions are the easy ones. An anion gained electrons, so you just add them to the next open spot in the normal Aufbau order. Fluorine has 9 electrons, 1s2 2s2 2p5, and its 2p sublevel has one empty spot. Fluorine gains 1 electron to become F− with 10 electrons, and that new electron fills the last 2p box: 1s2 2s2 2p6. In noble gas notation, F− is [He] 2s2 2p6, which is exactly the same as neon.

Configurations of Cations

  • Cations: remove e− from the highest n
Top row: Mg atom, 12 electrons, 1s2 2s2 2p6 3s2, with all orbital boxes through 3s filled with paired arrows. A red arrow labeled loses 2 electrons points down to the Mg2+ ion row: 10 electrons, 1s2 2s2 2p6, where the 3s box is now empty. Bottom line: [Ne] 3s2 becomes [Ne].

For cations, the big question is which electrons leave. The rule is to remove electrons from the highest energy level first. The energy level is n, the big number in front, like the 3 in 3s. Those outermost electrons are farthest from the nucleus, so they are held the least tightly. Magnesium has 12 electrons, 1s2 2s2 2p6 3s2, and its highest n is 3, so both 3s electrons leave. Mg2+ has 10 electrons and goes from [Ne] 3s2 to just [Ne], the same configuration as neon, just like F−.

Isoelectronic Ions

  • Isoelectronic: same number of e−
  • Same e− count = same configuration
Six cards in a row: N3− with 7 protons, O2− with 8 protons, F− with 9 protons, Ne with 10 protons, Na+ with 11 protons, and Mg2+ with 12 protons. Every card shows 10 electrons. Below the cards: all six are 1s2 2s2 2p6, which equals [Ne].

Isoelectronic means having the same number of electrons (“iso” means same). These six particles have 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, and 12 protons, so they are six different elements. But count the electrons: N3− is 7 + 3, O2− is 8 + 2, F− is 9 + 1, Ne is 10, Na+ is 11 − 1, and Mg2+ is 12 − 2. That is 10 electrons every time, so all six have neon’s configuration, 1s2 2s2 2p6. Quick tip: to find an ion’s electron count, start with the atomic number and subtract the charge. A negative charge adds electrons, and a positive charge removes them.

Ion size. Gaining or losing electrons also changes an atom’s size. A cation is smaller than its atom: Na+ has lost its only n = 3 electron, so it drops a whole energy level and shrinks from 186 pm to 102 pm. An anion is larger than its atom: Cl− has one extra electron in the same level, and the extra repulsion spreads the electron cloud out from 99 pm to 181 pm. In an isoelectronic series, the ion with the most protons is the smallest, because more protons pull the same number of electrons in tighter. For the 10-electron ions, the order from largest to smallest is O2− > F− > Na+ > Mg2+.

Transition Metal Ions

  • Lose 4s e− first (highest n), then 3d
Three rows of 4s and 3d orbital boxes. Fe atom, 26 electrons, [Ar] 4s2 3d6: 4s is paired and 3d has one pair and four single up arrows. A red arrow labeled loses 4s2 leads to Fe2+ ion, 24 electrons, [Ar] 3d6: 4s is empty and 3d is unchanged. A second red arrow labeled loses one 3d electron leads to Fe3+ ion, 23 electrons, [Ar] 3d5: 4s is empty and each of the five 3d boxes has one up arrow.

When we fill electrons, 4s fills before 3d. But when we remove electrons, the 4s electrons leave first. It is the same rule as before: remove from the highest n. The 4s sublevel has n = 4 and 3d has n = 3, so the 4s electrons are on the outside. Iron is [Ar] 4s2 3d6. To make Fe2+, both electrons come out of 4s, giving [Ar] 3d6. To make Fe3+, the 4s is already empty, so one electron comes out of 3d, giving [Ar] 3d5. A very common mistake is writing Fe2+ as [Ar] 4s2 3d4. That is wrong, so always empty 4s first.

Exceptions: Chromium

  • Half-filled 3d (5 e−) is extra stable
Two rows for chromium, 24 electrons. Expected: [Ar] 4s2 3d4, with a paired 4s box and four single up arrows in 3d leaving the fifth 3d box empty. Actual, in red: [Ar] 4s1 3d5, with one up arrow in 4s and one up arrow in every 3d box, the fifth one drawn in red. Caption: one 4s electron moves into 3d.

A few elements do not follow the Aufbau order exactly, and chromium is the first. With 24 electrons, we expect [Ar] 4s2 3d4, which leaves four arrows and one empty box in 3d. A half-filled d sublevel, with exactly one electron in each of the five boxes, is extra stable. Because the 4s and 3d energies are very close, it is worth it for one 4s electron to move up into 3d. The actual configuration is [Ar] 4s1 3d5, with six unpaired electrons. You need to memorize this exception.

Exceptions: Copper

  • Filled 3d (10 e−) is extra stable
Two rows for copper, 29 electrons. Expected: [Ar] 4s2 3d9, with a paired 4s box and four paired 3d boxes plus one 3d box holding a single up arrow. Actual, in red: [Ar] 4s1 3d10, with one up arrow in 4s and all five 3d boxes paired, the last down arrow drawn in red. Caption: one 4s electron moves into 3d. Footer: same pattern below them, Mo is like Cr and Ag is like Cu.

Copper has 29 electrons, so we expect [Ar] 4s2 3d9, which is one electron short of a completely full d sublevel. A filled d sublevel, with ten electrons, is also extra stable, so again one 4s electron moves up into 3d. The actual configuration is [Ar] 4s1 3d10. Remember the pattern: chromium moves an electron to make d half full, and copper moves an electron to make d completely full. The elements right below them do the same thing, so molybdenum acts like chromium and silver acts like copper.

↑ Back to top


Worked Examples

Try each problem on your own first, then open the solution to check your work.

Example 1: Configuration of an Anion

Write the noble gas configuration of the sulfide ion, S2−. Which noble gas has the same configuration?

Show the solution
  1. Count the electrons: S has Z = 16, so 16 e−. S2− gains 2: 16 + 2 = 18 e−
  2. Write the atom’s configuration: S: [Ne] 3s2 3p4 (10 + 2 + 4 = 16)
  3. Add the 2 electrons to the open orbitals: the 3p sublevel had room for 2 more, so S2−: [Ne] 3s2 3p6
  4. Compare to a noble gas: Ar has 18 e− and is [Ne] 3s2 3p6, so [Ne] 3s2 3p6 = [Ar]
  5. Answer: S2− = [Ne] 3s2 3p6, the same as argon (Ar)

Example 2: Configuration of a Cation

Write the full and noble gas configurations of the aluminum ion, Al3+.

Show the solution
  1. Count the electrons: Al has Z = 13, so 13 e−. Al3+ loses 3: 13 − 3 = 10 e−
  2. Write the atom’s configuration: Al: 1s2 2s2 2p6 3s2 3p1 (2 + 2 + 6 + 2 + 1 = 13)
  3. Remove 3 electrons from the highest n: n = 3 holds exactly 3 electrons (3s2 and 3p1), so all of them leave
  4. Answer: Al3+ = 1s2 2s2 2p6 = [Ne] (isoelectronic with neon)

Example 3: Isoelectronic Ions

Which of these ions are isoelectronic with argon, Ar? Ca2+, Na+, Cl−, P3−, Br−, K+

Show the solution
  1. Count argon’s electrons: Ar has Z = 18 and is neutral, so 18 e−
  2. Count the electrons in each ion: Ca2+: 20 − 2 = 18; Na+: 11 − 1 = 10; Cl−: 17 + 1 = 18; P3−: 15 + 3 = 18; Br−: 35 + 1 = 36; K+: 19 − 1 = 18
  3. Compare to 18: Ca2+, Cl−, P3−, and K+ match. Na+ (10 e−) matches neon, and Br− (36 e−) matches krypton.
  4. Answer: Ca2+, Cl−, P3−, and K+ are isoelectronic with Ar

Example 4: Transition Metal Ion Boxes

Draw the orbital box diagram for Mn2+ using noble gas notation. How many unpaired electrons does it have?

Show the solution
  1. Count the electrons: Mn has Z = 25, so 25 e−. Mn2+ loses 2: 25 − 2 = 23 e−
  2. Write the atom’s configuration: Mn: [Ar] 4s2 3d5 (18 + 2 + 5 = 25; manganese is not an exception)
  3. Remove 2 electrons from the highest n: both 4s electrons leave, so Mn2+: [Ar] 3d5
  4. Draw the orbital boxes: write [Ar], then five boxes labeled 3d with one up arrow in each box (Hund’s rule: one electron per box before pairing)
  5. Answer: Mn2+ = [Ar] 3d5, with 5 unpaired electrons (a half-filled d sublevel, like chromium)

↑ Back to top


Practice

Write configurations for anions, cations, and transition metal ions, draw an ion’s orbital boxes, and explain the chromium and copper exceptions. Try it on your own first, then check your work with the answer key.

Explore the periodic table

See every element’s properties, and color the table by atomic radius, electronegativity or ionization energy to see the trends.

↑ Back to top


Lesson Slides

↑ Back to top


Big Ideas

  • Ions form when atoms gain or lose e−
  • Main-group ions match a noble gas
  • Cations lose e− from the highest n (4s before 3d)
  • Cr and Cu: half-filled or filled 3d is extra stable

Back to the essential question: When atoms form ions, the protons stay the same and only the electrons change. Atoms gain electrons to become negative anions or lose electrons from the highest energy level to become positive cations, which for transition metals means 4s empties before 3d, and main-group ions usually end up isoelectronic with the nearest noble gas. Next up: Lewis Structures.

↑ Back to top


NGSS Alignment

This lesson builds toward these Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) performance expectations:

  • HS-PS1-1: Use the periodic table as a model to predict the relative properties of elements based on the patterns of electrons in the outermost energy level of atoms.

Disciplinary core ideas: PS1.A Structure and Properties of Matter

↑ Back to top