Chemistry · Quantum

Models of the Atom

Essential Question

How has our model of the atom changed?

Nobody has ever seen an atom the way we see a baseball. By the end of this lesson, you should be able to describe each major model of the atom, explain the evidence behind it, and draw a Bohr model yourself.

In short: the model of the atom changed as new evidence appeared: Dalton’s solid sphere (1803), Thomson’s plum pudding (1897), Rutherford’s nuclear model (1911), Bohr’s planetary model (1913), and Schrödinger’s quantum mechanical, or electron cloud, model (1926). The quantum model is the one scientists use today. It shows a small, positive nucleus surrounded by a cloud of negative electrons, where we can only describe the probability of finding an electron, not its exact path.

Video not loading? Watch it on YouTube.

Why Models Change

Cycle showing how scientific models change: a model makes predictions, experiments test them, new evidence appears, and the model is revised
  • Atoms are far too small to see directly, so scientists build models: simplified pictures that explain the evidence from experiments.
  • When an experiment gives new evidence that the old model can’t explain, the model gets revised. Then the cycle starts again.
  • Older models weren’t useless. They were not wrong, just incomplete.

Timeline of Atomic Models

Timeline of atomic models: Dalton 1803, Thomson 1897, Rutherford 1911, Bohr 1913, Schrodinger 1926
  • 1803, Dalton: solid sphere
  • 1897, Thomson: plum pudding
  • 1911, Rutherford: nuclear model
  • 1913, Bohr: planetary model
  • 1926, Schrödinger: electron cloud

Notice how fast things changed in the early 1900s. Every new experiment added evidence, and every new model explained a little more.

Dalton’s Model

Dalton's model: the atom as a solid, indivisible sphere
  • Atoms are tiny, solid spheres, like billiard balls.
  • Atoms cannot be divided.
  • All atoms of an element are identical.

Dalton got a lot right: matter really is made of atoms. But two of his ideas turned out to be wrong. Atoms contain smaller particles, and atoms of the same element can have different masses. Those are isotopes.

Thomson’s Model

Thomson's plum pudding model: negative electrons scattered through a sphere of spread-out positive charge
  • In 1897, Thomson used a cathode ray tube to discover the electron, the first subatomic particle ever found. So atoms can be divided.
  • Atoms are neutral, so there must also be positive charge. Thomson pictured negative electrons scattered through a sphere of positive charge.
  • This is called the plum pudding model. Think of chocolate chips in a cookie. There is no nucleus in this model.

Rutherford’s Gold Foil Experiment

Rutherford gold foil experiment: alpha particles from a source hit thin gold foil; most pass straight through, a few deflect, and very few bounce back
  • In 1911, Rutherford’s team fired small, fast, positive alpha (α) particles at a very thin sheet of gold foil.
  • Based on Thomson’s model, they expected every particle to pass right through the spread-out “pudding.”
  • Most went straight through. Some were deflected at angles. A very few bounced back.

Rutherford said it was as surprising as firing a cannonball at a piece of tissue paper and having it bounce back at you. Something small, dense, and positive had to be inside the atom.

Rutherford’s Nuclear Model

Rutherford's observations paired with conclusions: atom is mostly empty space, with a tiny, dense, positive nucleus
  • Most went straight through → the atom is mostly empty space.
  • A few bounced back → they hit something tiny, dense, and positive that repelled them: the nucleus. Since so few hit it, the nucleus must be extremely small compared to the whole atom.
  • Electrons are outside the nucleus, but Rutherford’s model didn’t explain where they were or how they moved. That’s the question Bohr tackled next.

Bohr’s Planetary Model

Bohr's planetary model with energy levels n=1, n=2 and n=3 around the nucleus, showing an electron jumping between levels
  • In 1913, Bohr placed electrons in circular orbits around the nucleus, like planets around the sun.
  • Electrons can only be in certain orbits, called energy levels (n = 1, 2, 3, …). Each level has a specific energy. Levels closer to the nucleus have lower energy.
  • An electron can’t be between levels, like you can stand on a rung of a ladder but not between rungs.
  • When an electron absorbs energy, it jumps up a level. When it falls back down, it releases that energy as light.

This explains why each element gives off specific colors of light, which we’ll study soon with emission spectra.

Drawing a Bohr Model

Bohr model of sodium-23: nucleus with 11 protons and 12 neutrons, electrons arranged 2, 8, 1
  1. Nucleus: protons = atomic number, neutrons = mass number − atomic number. Sodium-23 has 11 p+ and 23 − 11 = 12 n0.
  2. Electrons: a neutral atom has as many electrons as protons. Sodium has 11 e−.
  3. Fill from the inside out. For the first 20 elements, use the pattern 2, 8, 8, 2. Sodium: 2 in n = 1, 8 in n = 2, and the last 1 in n = 3.
  4. Check: 2 + 8 + 1 = 11 electrons.

You’ll learn later in this unit that the third level can actually hold more than 8, but this pattern works for the elements we’ll draw.

Quantum Mechanical Model

Quantum mechanical model: a fuzzy electron cloud around the nucleus, densest where an electron is most likely to be found
  • Bohr’s model worked for hydrogen but couldn’t explain atoms with more electrons. In 1926, Schrödinger used math to describe electrons as waves.
  • Electrons don’t travel in neat circular paths. An electron’s exact path can’t be known.
  • Instead, we describe the probability of finding an electron in a region of space. This is the electron cloud. Darker regions are where an electron is more likely to be found.

These regions of probability are called orbitals. The quantum mechanical model is the one scientists use today, and we’ll use it to write electron configurations in the rest of this unit.

Bohr vs. Quantum Model

Bohr modelQuantum model
ElectronsFixed circular orbitsCloud of probability
Electron pathExact path shownPath can’t be known
StrengthEasy to draw, shows energy levelsMost accurate, works for all atoms
WeaknessOnly works for hydrogenHarder to picture

A good rule: use Bohr to draw, use quantum to explain. Comparing the strengths and weaknesses of these two models is a common exam question, so know both sides.

↑ Back to top


Worked Examples

Try each problem on your own first, then open the solution to check your work.

Example 1: Identify the Model

Identify each model and the scientist who proposed it.

Three atomic model pictures labeled A, B and C for students to identify
Show the solution
  1. Model A: a nucleus with electrons in circular rings (energy levels) → Bohr, planetary model
  2. Model B: no nucleus, electrons scattered through a positive sphere → Thomson, plum pudding model
  3. Model C: a nucleus surrounded by a fuzzy cloud, no paths shown → Schrödinger, quantum mechanical (electron cloud) model

Example 2: Draw a Bohr Model

Draw a Bohr model of a neutral aluminum-27 atom. Label the nucleus and each energy level.

Show the solution
  1. Protons: aluminum’s atomic number is 13, so it has 13 p+.
  2. Neutrons: 27 − 13 = 14 n0.
  3. Electrons: the atom is neutral, so it has 13 e−.
  4. Fill from the inside out: 2 in n = 1, 8 in n = 2, and the remaining 3 in n = 3. Check: 2 + 8 + 3 = 13.

Answer: nucleus with 13 p+ and 14 n0; electrons arranged 2, 8, 3

Completed Bohr model of aluminum-27: 13 protons and 14 neutrons in the nucleus, electrons arranged 2, 8, 3

Example 3: Explain the Evidence

In Rutherford’s experiment, a few alpha particles bounced straight back. Explain what this showed and why it ruled out Thomson’s model.

Show the solution
  1. Claim: the atom has a tiny, dense, positive nucleus.
  2. Evidence: a few positive alpha particles bounced straight back from the gold foil.
  3. Reasoning: like charges repel. To turn a fast alpha particle around, it had to hit positive charge packed into a very small, dense space. In Thomson’s model, the positive charge is spread out through the whole atom, so it could never be concentrated enough to bounce a particle back.

Sample answer: The alpha particles that bounced back must have hit a tiny, dense, positive nucleus that repelled them. Thomson’s model had its positive charge spread out like pudding, which could not be concentrated enough to bounce a particle back, so his model was ruled out.

Example 4: Fix the Misconception

A student says electrons travel in circular paths around the nucleus, like planets around the sun. Which model is this? What does the modern model say instead?

Show the solution
  1. Name the model: circular orbits like planets is the Bohr (planetary) model.
  2. Modern model: the quantum mechanical model says an electron’s exact path can’t be known.
  3. Instead: we describe the probability of finding an electron in a region of space.

Sample answer: The student is describing Bohr’s planetary model. The quantum mechanical model says an electron’s exact path can’t be known. Electrons are found in regions of probability called orbitals (the electron cloud), not in circular orbits.

↑ Back to top


Practice

Match descriptions to models of the atom, find particles in isotopes, draw Bohr models, and explain the evidence. Try it on your own first, then check your work with the answer key.

↑ Back to top


Lesson Slides

↑ Back to top


Big Ideas

  • Models change when new evidence appears.
  • Thomson found the electron.
  • Rutherford found the nucleus.
  • Bohr: electrons in fixed energy levels.
  • Quantum model: an electron cloud of probability.

Back to the essential question: our model of the atom went from a solid ball, to a pudding, to a nucleus with orbits, to a nucleus surrounded by an electron cloud. Each change was driven by new evidence. Next, we’ll use the quantum model to describe exactly where electrons are with orbital filling diagrams.

↑ Back to top


NGSS Alignment

This lesson builds toward these Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) performance expectations:

  • HS-PS1-1: Use the periodic table as a model to predict the relative properties of elements based on the patterns of electrons in the outermost energy level of atoms.

Disciplinary core ideas: PS1.A Structure and Properties of Matter

↑ Back to top