AP Chemistry · Unit 3: Properties of Substances and Mixtures

3.10 Solubility

Essential Question

Why do some substances dissolve and others don’t?

Sugar disappears when you stir it into water, but oil floats on top no matter how hard you stir. By the end of this lesson, you should be able to explain the difference using intermolecular forces.

Video not loading? Watch it on YouTube.

Solute and Solvent

  • Solution: a homogeneous mixture, the same all the way through
  • Solute: the substance that dissolves
  • Solvent: the substance it dissolves in (usually present in the greater amount)
  • When water is the solvent, the solution is aqueous, written (aq). NaCl(aq) means sodium chloride dissolved in water.
A beaker of water with orange sugar particles spread evenly through the liquid. Caption: sugar dissolved in water.

Like Dissolves Like

Substances with similar intermolecular forces tend to dissolve in each other or mix. This is the big rule for this topic, straight from the AP course framework.

SoluteWater (polar, H-bonds)Hexane (nonpolar, LDFs only)
Ionic or polarDissolvesDoes not dissolve
NonpolarDoes not dissolveDissolves

Polar goes with polar, and nonpolar goes with nonpolar.

Dissolving: Break and Form Attractions

  1. Solute particles pull apart. Solute-solute attractions break.
  2. Solvent particles make room. Solvent-solvent attractions break.
  3. Solute and solvent attract. New solute-solvent attractions form.
Three panels with arrows between them: 1, solute particles pull apart; 2, solvent particles make room around an empty space; 3, a solute particle surrounded by solvent particles.

A substance dissolves well when the new attractions are about as strong as the ones broken. If the new attractions are much weaker, the particles stay with their own kind, and the substance won’t dissolve much. That’s the particle-level reason like dissolves like works.

Ionic Compounds in Water

  • Water is polar: the O end is partially negative (δ−) and the H ends are partially positive (δ+).
  • The O end faces cations (positive ions).
  • The H end faces anions (negative ions).
  • An attraction between an ion and a polar molecule is an ion-dipole attraction.
A K+ cation surrounded by six water molecules with their red oxygen atoms facing the ion, and a Cl- anion surrounded by six water molecules with a white hydrogen atom pointing at the ion. Legend: red is O (partial negative), white is H (partial positive).

Exam tip: when you draw ions in water, make sure the correct end of each water molecule points at the ion. Oxygen toward cations, hydrogen toward anions.

Miscible or Immiscible?

  • Miscible: liquids mix in any amount and form one layer.
  • Immiscible: liquids form separate layers.
Test tube A, water plus ethanol, shows one uniform layer. Test tube B, water plus hexane, shows two layers with hexane floating on top of water.

Water and ethanol are miscible because ethanol has an O-H group that can hydrogen bond with water. Water and hexane are immiscible because water is polar and hexane is nonpolar. Hexane is less dense than water, so it floats on top.

Why Oil and Water Separate

  • Water molecules hydrogen bond to each other.
  • Hexane has only weak London dispersion forces (LDFs).
  • Water stays together, and hexane is pushed out into its own layer.
Particle view of a container: gray hexane molecules in a top layer, and water molecules in the bottom layer linked to each other by dashed hydrogen bonds.

If a hexane molecule squeezed in between water molecules, it would break up hydrogen bonds but could only offer weak dispersion forces in return. Water and hexane don’t repel each other. Water molecules are just much more attracted to each other than to hexane.

Nonpolar Solvents

  • I2 is nonpolar, so its only intermolecular forces are LDFs.
  • It dissolves well in hexane, which also has only LDFs.
  • It barely dissolves in water.
A test tube after shaking: a violet top layer of hexane with dissolved iodine, and a pale bottom layer of water.

Shake iodine with water and hexane, and the iodine moves into the hexane layer, which turns violet. Iodine can’t form attractions with water strong enough to make up for breaking water’s hydrogen bonds.

Alcohols: Polar and Nonpolar Parts

  • The O-H group can hydrogen bond with water.
  • The carbon chain is nonpolar (LDFs only).
  • Longer chain → less soluble in water.
Three alcohols drawn as a red OH group attached to a chain of gray carbon atoms: methanol with 1 carbon mixes completely, 1-butanol with 4 carbons is partly soluble, and 1-octanol with 8 carbons is barely soluble.

Each molecule has just one O-H group, but the nonpolar part keeps growing. The longer the nonpolar chain, the less the molecule is like water, so the less soluble it is in water.

↑ Back to top


Worked Examples

Try each problem on your own first, then open the solution to check your work.

Example 1: Comparing Solubility in Water

Which is more soluble in water, NH3 or CH4? Justify your answer using intermolecular forces.

Show the solution
  1. IMFs in NH3: H atoms are bonded directly to N, and N has a lone pair. NH3 is polar and can hydrogen bond.
  2. IMFs in CH4: tetrahedral and symmetric, so it’s nonpolar. LDFs only.
  3. IMFs in the solvent: water is polar and hydrogen bonds.
  4. Answer: NH3 is more soluble in water. Like dissolves like.

Sample exam justification: NH3 can form hydrogen bonds with water molecules, and these attractions are similar in strength to the hydrogen bonds broken between water molecules. CH4 can only form weak dispersion forces with water, which don’t make up for breaking water’s hydrogen bonds.

Example 2: Choosing a Solvent

Which is more soluble in hexane, CCl4 or KBr? Justify your answer.

Show the solution
  1. IMFs in the solvent: hexane is nonpolar, so it only has LDFs.
  2. Classify KBr: ionic. The attractions between K+ and Br− ions are very strong, and hexane has no partial charges to form ion-dipole attractions.
  3. Classify CCl4: each C-Cl bond is polar, but the molecule is tetrahedral and symmetric, so the bond dipoles cancel. CCl4 is nonpolar with LDFs only.
  4. Answer: CCl4 is more soluble in hexane.

Sample exam justification: CCl4 and hexane are both nonpolar and have only dispersion forces, so they mix well. Hexane can’t form attractions strong enough to replace the ionic attractions in solid KBr, so KBr won’t dissolve.

Example 3: Ion-Dipole Diagrams

Which diagram correctly shows water molecules around a Na+ ion? Explain.

Two diagrams of a Na+ ion surrounded by six water molecules. In diagram A, the red oxygen atoms face the ion. In diagram B, white hydrogen atoms point toward the ion.
Show the solution
  1. Charge on the ion: Na+ is positive.
  2. Which end of water is attracted: a positive ion attracts the negative end of water, the oxygen (red).
  3. Check each diagram: in A, the oxygen atoms point toward Na+. In B, the hydrogen atoms point toward it.
  4. Answer: Diagram A is correct.

Sample exam justification: Oxygen’s partial negative charge is attracted to the positive sodium ion. Diagram B places partially positive hydrogen atoms next to a positive ion, and like charges repel.

Example 4: Attractions Broken and Formed

When LiCl(s) dissolves in water, which attractions are broken and which are formed?

LiCl(s) → Li+(aq) + Cl−(aq)

Show the solution
  1. What happens to the solute: solid LiCl separates into Li+ and Cl− ions, and each ion ends up surrounded by water.
  2. Broken: the ionic attractions between Li+ and Cl− in the crystal, and some hydrogen bonds between water molecules (so the water can make room for the ions).
  3. Formed: ion-dipole attractions. Li+ attracts the O end of water molecules, and Cl− attracts the H end.

LiCl is very soluble in water because these ion-dipole attractions are strong enough to make up for the attractions that were broken.

↑ Back to top


Practice

Practice with instant feedback

Answer original AP-style questions for Unit 3 and see an explanation right after each one. Choose Topic 3.10 or mix topics. No login needed.

↑ Back to top


Lesson Slides

↑ Back to top


Big Ideas

  • Like dissolves like: similar IMFs mix.
  • Dissolving breaks attractions, then forms new ones.
  • Ions dissolve in water by ion-dipole attractions.
  • Longer nonpolar chain → less soluble in water.

Back to the essential question: a substance dissolves when the solute and solvent can attract each other about as strongly as they were attracted to themselves. Water and hexane can’t, so they stay in separate layers. Next up, Topic 3.11 looks at how molecules interact with light across the electromagnetic spectrum.

↑ Back to top


AP Alignment

This lesson covers Topic 3.10, Solubility, in Unit 3 (Properties of Substances and Mixtures) of the College Board AP Chemistry Course and Exam Description (CED). Learning objective:

  • 3.10.A: Explain the relationship between the solubility of ionic and molecular compounds in aqueous and nonaqueous solvents, and the intermolecular interactions between particles.

Essential knowledge: 3.10.A.1

Suggested skill: 4.D Model Analysis. Explain the degree to which a model or representation describes the connection between particulate-level properties and macroscopic properties.

↑ Back to top