In this lesson
Take it with you
- Lesson slides (PDF)
- Practice worksheet (PDF)
- Answer key (PDF)
- AP Chemistry Unit 3 Practice (activity)
Essential Question
How do intermolecular forces help us separate a solution?
By the end of this lesson, you should be able to explain why filtration cannot separate a solution, and use differences in intermolecular forces to explain the results of chromatography and distillation.
Video not loading? Watch it on YouTube.
Why Not Filtration?
- Filtration only removes undissolved solids, like sand in water.
- Dissolved particles, like salt ions or sugar molecules, are far smaller than the holes in filter paper, so they pass right through.
- To separate the parts of a solution, we need methods based on differences in intermolecular forces (IMFs).

The sand grains never dissolved, so they get caught on the filter paper. Everything that dissolved is spread out as individual particles and passes through with the water.
Separation Methods

Filtration separates by particle size, so it only works on heterogeneous mixtures. For a solution, chromatography separates components by how strongly they are attracted to two different phases, and distillation separates them by boiling point. Both come down to differences in IMFs.
Chromatography Setup
- Stationary phase: stays in place. In paper chromatography, this is the paper.
- Mobile phase: the solvent, which moves up the paper by capillary action and carries the sample with it.
- Solvent front: the line where the solvent stops moving.

Two lab details matter. Draw the start line in pencil, because pen ink would separate too. Keep the solvent level below the start line, or the sample dissolves into the beaker instead of traveling up the paper.
How Chromatography Separates
Every component in the mixture is attracted to both phases, like a tug of war. The mobile phase pulls each component along, and the stationary phase holds it back.

- More strongly attracted to the mobile phase → travels farther
- More strongly attracted to the stationary phase → stays near the start
- Different IMF strengths lead to different distances, and that is how the mixture separates.
Polarity and Distance
Chromatography paper is made of cellulose, which has many O-H groups, so the paper is polar. Polar components stick to it through dipole-dipole forces and hydrogen bonding.
| Stationary phase | Mobile phase | Travels farthest |
|---|---|---|
| Polar (paper) | Less polar solvent | Least polar component |
| Nonpolar coating | Polar solvent (water) | Most polar component |
Like attracts like: the component that is most similar to the mobile phase travels the farthest. A chromatogram can be used to infer the relative polarities of the components in a mixture.
Types of Chromatography

- Paper: the stationary phase is the paper.
- Thin-layer (TLC): a glass or plastic plate coated with a thin layer of solid, usually silica.
- Column: a tube packed with solid. Solvent is poured in at the top, and each component can be collected as it comes out the bottom.
Different equipment, same idea: components separate based on their attraction to the stationary phase versus the mobile phase.
Retention Factor (Rf)
Rf = distance spot traveled ÷ distance solvent traveled

- Measure both distances from the start line.
- Rf is always between 0 and 1 and has no units, because the centimeters cancel.
- Higher Rf → more attracted to the mobile phase. Lower Rf → more attracted to the stationary phase.
Distillation
- Separates liquids with different boiling points.
- Heat the mixture: the component with the lower boiling point vaporizes first.
- The condenser, cooled by flowing water, turns the vapor back into a liquid called the distillate.

The thermometer at the top measures the temperature of the vapor that is leaving the flask, so you can tell which component is coming over.
Distillation and IMFs
- Weaker IMFs → higher vapor pressure → lower boiling point
- The component with the weaker IMFs boils off first.
- Ethanol (78 °C) distills before water (100 °C).

Both ethanol and water hydrogen bond, but water can form more hydrogen bonds per molecule, so its IMFs are stronger overall. Ethanol escapes into the vapor more easily, so the vapor above the mixture is mostly ethanol. The first distillate is rich in ethanol, but it will not be perfectly pure.
Worked Examples
Try each problem on your own first, then open the solution to check your work.
Example 1: Calculating Rf
In a paper chromatography experiment, the solvent front moved 8.0 cm from the start line. A red dye moved 2.4 cm. What is the Rf value of the red dye?
Show the solution
- Given: distance solvent traveled = 8.0 cm, distance spot traveled = 2.4 cm. Find Rf.
- Equation: Rf = distance spot traveled ÷ distance solvent traveled
- Substitute: Rf = 2.4 cm ÷ 8.0 cm. The centimeters cancel, so there are no units.
- Solve: 2.4 ÷ 8.0 = 0.30
- Answer: Rf = 0.30 (2 significant figures, no units)
Check: 0.30 is between 0 and 1, so it makes sense. Since the Rf is low, the red dye is more attracted to the paper than to the solvent.
Example 2: Reading a Chromatogram
Three dyes were separated on polar paper using a nonpolar solvent. Which dye is the most polar? Justify your answer using intermolecular forces.

Show the solution
- Identify the phases: the stationary phase (paper) is polar. The mobile phase (solvent) is nonpolar.
- Compare distances from the start line: A traveled the farthest, C a medium distance, and B the shortest.
- Connect to IMFs: B stayed closest to the start, so it has the strongest attraction to the polar paper, through dipole-dipole forces or hydrogen bonding.
- Answer: Dye B is the most polar. It traveled the shortest distance, which shows it has the strongest intermolecular attractions to the polar paper.
Bonus: Dye A is the least polar. It was most attracted to the nonpolar solvent, so it traveled the farthest.
Example 3: Predicting Distillation Order
A mixture of pentane (C5H12) and hexane (C6H14) is distilled. Which compound collects first in the receiving flask? Justify your answer using intermolecular forces.
Show the solution
- Identify the IMFs: both are hydrocarbons, so both are nonpolar. Their only IMFs are London dispersion forces (LDFs).
- Compare sizes: hexane has one more carbon, so it has more electrons and a larger, more polarizable electron cloud. Pentane has weaker LDFs.
- Connect to boiling point: weaker LDFs → higher vapor pressure → lower boiling point. Pentane boils at about 36 °C, and hexane at about 69 °C.
- Answer: Pentane collects first. It has a smaller electron cloud, so it has weaker London dispersion forces, a higher vapor pressure, and a lower boiling point than hexane.
Example 4: Choosing a Method
Choose the best method to separate each mixture, and explain your choice: (a) sand and water, (b) ethanol and water, (c) the dyes in black ink.
Show the solution
- (a) Sand and water: filtration. Sand does not dissolve, so it is caught by the filter paper while the water passes through.
- (b) Ethanol and water: distillation. They form a solution, so filtration will not work. They have different IMF strengths and different boiling points, so ethanol boils off first.
- (c) Dyes in black ink: chromatography. The dyes are dissolved and have different polarities, so they are attracted differently to the stationary and mobile phases and spread into separate spots.
Practice
- 3.9 Separation of Solutions and Mixtures Practice Worksheet (PDF)
- 3.9 Separation of Solutions and Mixtures Practice Answer Key (PDF)
Practice with instant feedback
Answer original AP-style questions for Unit 3 and see an explanation right after each one. Choose Topic 3.9 or mix topics. No login needed.
Lesson Slides
Big Ideas
- Filtration only separates undissolved solids. It cannot separate the parts of a solution.
- Chromatography separates components by their attraction to the stationary phase versus the mobile phase.
- Rf = distance spot traveled ÷ distance solvent traveled, always between 0 and 1.
- In distillation, the component with weaker IMFs has a higher vapor pressure and boils off first.
Exam tip: on free-response questions, do not stop at “it is more polar.” Name the IMF and say which phase the component is more attracted to. You may also be asked to identify or sketch a lab setup, so know the parts of a chromatography setup and a distillation apparatus.
Back to the essential question: intermolecular forces let us separate a solution because components with different IMF strengths travel different distances in chromatography and boil at different temperatures in distillation. Next up, Topic 3.10 explains why some substances dissolve and others do not.
AP Alignment
This lesson covers Topic 3.9, Separation of Solutions and Mixtures, in Unit 3 (Properties of Substances and Mixtures) of the College Board AP Chemistry Course and Exam Description (CED). Learning objective:
- 3.9.A: Explain the results of a separation experiment based on intermolecular interactions.
Essential knowledge: 3.9.A.1
Suggested skill: 2.C Question and Method. Identify experimental procedures that are aligned to the question (which may include a sketch of a lab setup).